Wing-Off 25 Hot Rod’s BBQ vs Marley’s Gotham Grill – The Best Wings In New Jersey

WING-OFF 25: Saturday, June 20, 2015
– Hot Rod’s BBQ vs. Marleys’ Gotham Grill
AKA 1st Best Wings In NJ

Hot Rod’s BBQ
175 N Main St
Wharton, NJ 07885

Marley’s Gotham Grill 
169 Main St
Hackettstown, NJ 07840

Wing-Off member and Big Brother Season 13 cast member, Adam Poch was invited to join the NJ Munchmobile on a statewide search for the best Wings.

From – Alex Remnick/The Star-Ledger

Honestly, we were a little upset that he didn’t find a way to work us into the NJ Munchmobile event.  Once completed, he came back to the NYC Wing-Off crew with his findings. Adam wanted to only take us to the best of the best so he organized the very first ever NJ Wing-Off.

He was forgiven.

If you’re into classic cars, craft beer whiskey & smoked meats (who isn’t!?!?!), Hot Rod’s is for you. Owners Anthony & Toby Sibona have taken all their favorite things in life and combined them into one rocket-fueled eatery in North Jersey. The Sibona’s don’t tie their place into anyone style of BBQ, opting rather to borrow their favorites form different geographics. They call this hybrid style “Yankee BBQ.”


Their menu has all the meat goodies you expect from a barbecue restaurant like pulled pork, brisket, ribs, bbq’d chicken and more. But Hot Rod’s takes it a step further by offering them as is or in new-school style dishes like a brisket cheesesteak, maple bourbon bbq chicken sandwich and pulled pork mini egg rolls.

The one that caught our eye — smoked bacon wrapped burnt ends. “Chunks of BBQ burnt ends coated with sweet & spicy bbq sauce & spicy cajun seasoning then wrapped with applewood smoked bacon and re-smoked for tender, juicy brisket exploding with flavor.”


Yeah, you don’t see that and not order it!!!

From there, it was on to the wings. Hot Rod’s takes their wings and first coats them in proprietary seasoning. From there, the Wings are then smoked in their pit for about 3 hours. Once adequately smoked, the wings are then flash fried and then coated with your choice of sauce.


Hot Rod’s BBQ offers three flavors of wings:

  1. Signature Sweet & Spicy
  2. Buffalo Spicy
  3. Naked No Sauce

… unless you are the NYC Wing-Off crew!! Adam, being the man of flavor that he is, asked if they could make us a basket of wings using the the maple bourbon bbq sauce. He’s a good person to take eating with you. Hot Rod’s obliged!


We gobbled our way through each of them, barely taking a moment to breath. These are not your average wings. The smokiness from the pit really comes out in the overall flavor as does the seasoning rub. Most wings, all you taste is the chicken and the sauce but these two elements bring something to the wing that makes them very different and unique.

We crushed through 24 wings and if you head to Hot Rod’s BBQ, we suggest you do the same — try them all.


Let’s set the tone right on this one. Marley’s Gotham Grill is located in Hackettstown, NJ. It’s 53 miles West of Manhattan. You’re not going to drive all the way out here for just any old chicken wing. To me, Hackettstown is the middle of nowhere and when you arrive there, you’ll think the same.

But take a look at the photo above. That’s a basket of Marley’s Mac & Cheese Wings. That’s level of game we are talking about here. And that’s only the beginning.


Marley’s offers 101 different Wing flavors and the menu is constantly changing.


To a crew like us, this is like staring into the eyes of oblivion. It’s a never ending list of delights and as soon as you see one you want, you see another one that splits your skull. Focus. We had to focus. Each person on the Wing-Off was asked to chose one Wing, no vetos allowed.


Only Marley’s owner, Bruno Pascale, was allowed to veto our order to ensure that we chose the best of the best. Marley’s goes through 35,000 wings per month so we felt pretty secure in letting Bruno help us choose.
Rollercoaster – a mix of 7 different sauces.

Chicken Gone Wild – tossed in Nutella chocolate rolled in bacon and candied walnuts.

wing-off-25-hot-rods-bbq-marleys-gotham-grill-michaels-roscommon-hot-wings-5450  Nacho – spicy blend with nacho cheese

Raging Bull – hot sauce, cherry peepers, & pepperoncini

wing-off-25-hot-rods-bbq-marleys-gotham-grill-michaels-roscommon-hot-wings-5473Hot Old Bay

Kick’in Chicken – a concoction of dried spice’s (crushed red, garlic, orange peel, red bell pepper, onion, etc)

wing-off-25-hot-rods-bbq-marleys-gotham-grill-michaels-roscommon-hot-wings-5497Chicken Alfredo

Mystic – coconut curry sauce

Piggy Back – bacon cheddar

Bang Bang – sweet Thai & Sriracha


OK, so maybe we ordered more than 1 per person. And maybe, after all that, we ordered more because, heck, when were we going to be in Hackettstown again?

wing-off-25-hot-rods-bbq-marleys-gotham-grill-michaels-roscommon-hot-wings-5531 Fluff a Nutter

The God Father – cherry peppers, mozzarella, garlic, basil & tomato sauce
Can’t remember which wings these were. The brain was mush by this point.

Marley’s Gotham Grill is not wing paradise. It’s not even wing vahalla. This is a wing fantasy put together by a food genius on the scale of Willy Wonka.

If you ask each person on the Wing-Off which was their favorite, you are likely to get a different answer from each person. The diversity of flavors and palettes is so wide that you could drive an 18-wheeler through it. If one of these sounds good to you, it most certainly is worth trying. Old Bay and Fluff A Nutter were definitely highlights.


Declaring a winner in these contests can be taken the wrong way. We only eat the best of the best wings out there. If by chance we eat some wings that truly are terrible, we wouldn’t post about them. We wouldn’t share that experience with you. The Wing-Off is about discovering the absolute most tasty and wonderful wings out there and helping people to find them. Declaring a winner is just something we do because it makes it a little more fun.

The food at Hot Rod’s, especially the Wings are very unique and worth you checking out. The wings at Marley’s are absolutely insane and from another universe. A wing traditionalist might have a problem with both of these concepts but a wing lover would revel in the creativity.

Bruno Pascale is a wing junkie. He is cut from similar cloth as we are. When he makes wings and create flavors, he is trying to blow himself away first. If it makes it to the menu, you know it’s passed his test. Now that we’ve eaten there, we can definitely say that Bruno’s wing skill is like none other.



Michael’s Roscommon House
531 Joralemon St
Belleville, NJ 07109

After eating wings at Marley’s in Hackettstown, we all hopped in our cars and headed home. One of the cars decided that more wings were needed. They pulled off in Belleville NJ and had more. Because the entire group was not involved, it was not considered part of the Wing-Off.


Michaels Roscommon is an Irish pub / sports bar that’s been in business since 1982. The bar is family-owned and operated and has won many awards for their food, including being voted best Hamburger in NJ by the Munch-Mobile, Star Ledger. Part bar, part family-restaurant, they offer a full pub-menu from apps, soups, salads, sandwiches, pasta and Irish faves like Shepherd’s Pie, Fish & Chips and more.

Along with your standard buffalo wings available in array of different sauces categorized by heat. Michael’s Roscommon House has two types of wings on the menu. One of which was a Mac n Cheese wing but since we already had that experience today and stomach room was in limited quantity, we opted out.

wing-off-25-hot-rods-bbq-marleys-gotham-grill-michaels-roscommon-hot-wings-5561Scorned Woman – the hottest of the hot wings available.

“Jersey Wings” – a secret recipe described only as “garlic & cheese.”

Michael’s Roscommon had the most stylistically typical buffalo wings of the day and if that’s what you are looking for, they will deliver that experience.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *