Wing-Off 7 – Town Tavern vs. Wogies

– Town Tavern vs. Wogie’s

As reigning champ Scruff Duffy’s and their legacy Lansdowne remain undefeated, we have decided to retire them for the time being to make room for new challengers.

Town Tavern
134 West 3rd St
New York, NY 10012

39 Greenwich Ave
New York, NY 10014


Kudos to Town Tavern for giving us not only a private table but also in a private room and with the Giants / Eagles game on the TV! Which was good because the Town Tavern is an Eagles bar the Wing-Off crew is made of primary non-Eagles fans!! After a Jameson shot with our waitress Kat and a round of beers, it was time to start em up; 40 medium and 40 hot!

The medium were fantastic and in what might be the first time ever, better than the hot! They had a nice buttery taste with the right amount of hot sauce. You could actually get a good taste of the chicken. Although not a factor in our decision, the blue cheese was thick and creamy…just the way we like it! A couple of beers and some very, very friendly service from Tabitha and Kat and we were on our way.



This place is new on the scene but making a quick buzz. Although their claim is “NYC’s Best Philly Cheesesteak” we heard the wings were top notch. They held us a table in the back corner and within seconds, the excitement was at top level. Check out the menu; pictures of owner Aaron’s dad, cheesesteaks, garbage bread, fried a mozzarella bread and of course “Krazy Kate’s Wings!”

We place a gut buster bomb of an order with our fantastic server, Kristin: 20 medium, 20 hot, 3 cheesesteaks, waffle fries with ranch, gravy and cheese and enough $3 Yuneglings to drown a small village.

The wings were delicious. Hot, tasty, breaded just right and cooked perfectly. It was not going to be an easy decision. The cheesesteaks were pretty decent and the fries were good too. But the real winner were the special salt and pepper wings that Aaron had prepared especially for us. WOW. Talk about amazing! Doug and Dan went in for a 2nd order. But, not a factor on the decision.

Wing_Off_7_NYC_Best_hot_wings_old_town_tavern_wogies_120708_013 Wing_Off_7_NYC_Best_hot_wings_old_town_tavern_wogies_120708_019

Congratulations, you advance in the standings. To be fair, both places were fantastic and you couldn’t lose slopping up wings at either Town Tavern or Wogie’s.


1 Comment

  1. Hey there, if you plan on doing a Wing-Off 8, I'd love to help out in any way I can.

    I run a Wing Review Blog…so anytime I hear anything about wings, I'm down!

    you can also email me at

    Would love to have you as a guest reviewer sometime!

    – Pete

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *